| Name, Position and Team | Total Score |
| Vinatieri, Adam K, Indianapolis Colts | 50 |
| Vinatieri, Adam K, Indianapolis Colts | 50 |
| Gostkowski, Stephen K, New England Patriots | 34 |
| Gostkowski, Stephen K, New England Patriots | 34 |
| Gould, Robbie K, Chicago Bears | 25 |
| Gould, Robbie K, Chicago Bears | 25 |
| Jones, Thomas RB, Chicago Bears | 24 |
| Jones, Thomas RB, Chicago Bears | 24 |
| Westbrook, Brian RB, Philadelphia Eagles | 18 |
| Westbrook, Brian RB, Philadelphia Eagles | 18 |
| Akers, David K, Philadelphia Eagles | 18 |
| Akers, David K, Philadelphia Eagles | 18 |
| Manning, Peyton QB, Indianapolis Colts | 16 |
| Manning, Peyton QB, Indianapolis Colts | 16 |
| Brady, Tom QB, New England Patriots | 15 |
| Brady, Tom QB, New England Patriots | 15 |
| Brown, Josh K, Seattle Seahawks | 13 |
| Brown, Josh K, Seattle Seahawks | 13 |
| Addai, Joseph RB, Indianapolis Colts | 12 |
| Addai, Joseph RB, Indianapolis Colts | 12 |
| Gaffney, Jabar WR, New England Patriots | 12 |
| Gaffney, Jabar WR, New England Patriots | 12 |
| Dillon, Corey RB, New England Patriots | 12 |
| Dillon, Corey RB, New England Patriots | 12 |
| Bush, Reggie RB, New Orleans Saints | 12 |
| Bush, Reggie RB, New Orleans Saints | 12 |
| McAllister, Deuce RB, New Orleans Saints | 12 |
| McAllister, Deuce RB, New Orleans Saints | 12 |
| Burress, Plaxico WR, New York Giants | 12 |
| Burress, Plaxico WR, New York Giants | 12 |
| New England Patriots Team Defense | 12 |
| New England Patriots Team Defense | 12 |
| Berrian, Bernard WR, Chicago Bears | 12 |
| Berrian, Bernard WR, Chicago Bears | 12 |
| Stallworth, Donte' WR, Philadelphia Eagles | 12 |
| Stallworth, Donte' WR, Philadelphia Eagles | 12 |
| Stevens, Jerramy TE, Seattle Seahawks | 12 |
| Stevens, Jerramy TE, Seattle Seahawks | 12 |
| Alexander, Shaun RB, Seattle Seahawks | 12 |
| Alexander, Shaun RB, Seattle Seahawks | 12 |
| Tomlinson, LaDainian RB, San Diego Chargers | 12 |
| Tomlinson, LaDainian RB, San Diego Chargers | 12 |
| Wayne, Reggie WR, Indianapolis Colts | 12 |
| Wayne, Reggie WR, Indianapolis Colts | 12 |
| Carney, John K, New Orleans Saints | 11 |
| Carney, John K, New Orleans Saints | 11 |
| Gramatica, Martin K, Dallas Cowboys | 9 |
| Gramatica, Martin K, Dallas Cowboys | 9 |
| Brees, Drew QB, New Orleans Saints | 9 |
| Brees, Drew QB, New Orleans Saints | 9 |
| Grossman, Rex QB, Chicago Bears | 9 |
| Grossman, Rex QB, Chicago Bears | 9 |
| Hasselbeck, Matt QB, Seattle Seahawks | 9 |
| Hasselbeck, Matt QB, Seattle Seahawks | 9 |
| Chicago Bears Team Defense | 8 |
| Chicago Bears Team Defense | 8 |
| Feely, Jay K, New York Giants | 8 |
| Feely, Jay K, New York Giants | 8 |
| Faulk, Kevin RB, New England Patriots | 8 |
| Faulk, Kevin RB, New England Patriots | 8 |
| Stover, Matt K, Baltimore Ravens | 7 |
| Stover, Matt K, Baltimore Ravens | 7 |
| Nugent, Mike K, New York Jets | 7 |
| Nugent, Mike K, New York Jets | 7 |
| Turner, Michael RB, San Diego Chargers | 6 |
| Turner, Michael RB, San Diego Chargers | 6 |
| Benson, Cedric RB, Chicago Bears | 6 |
| Benson, Cedric RB, Chicago Bears | 6 |
| Rhodes, Dominic RB, Indianapolis Colts | 6 |
| Rhodes, Dominic RB, Indianapolis Colts | 6 |
| Burleson, Nate WR, Seattle Seahawks | 6 |
| Burleson, Nate WR, Seattle Seahawks | 6 |
| Muhammad, Muhsin WR, Chicago Bears | 6 |
| Muhammad, Muhsin WR, Chicago Bears | 6 |
| Manning, Eli QB, New York Giants | 6 |
| Manning, Eli QB, New York Giants | 6 |
| Caldwell, Reche WR, New England Patriots | 6 |
| Caldwell, Reche WR, New England Patriots | 6 |
| Graham, Daniel TE, New England Patriots | 6 |
| Graham, Daniel TE, New England Patriots | 6 |
| Colston, Marques WR, New Orleans Saints | 6 |
| Colston, Marques WR, New Orleans Saints | 6 |
| Cotchery, Jerricho WR, New York Jets | 6 |
| Cotchery, Jerricho WR, New York Jets | 6 |
| Crayton, Patrick WR, Dallas Cowboys | 6 |
| Crayton, Patrick WR, Dallas Cowboys | 6 |
| Dallas Cowboys Team Defense | 6 |
| Dallas Cowboys Team Defense | 6 |
| Indianapolis Colts Team Defense | 6 |
| Indianapolis Colts Team Defense | 6 |
| Garcia, Jeff QB, Philadelphia Eagles | 6 |
| Garcia, Jeff QB, Philadelphia Eagles | 6 |
| Gonzalez, Tony TE, Kansas City Chiefs | 6 |
| Gonzalez, Tony TE, Kansas City Chiefs | 6 |
| Green, Trent QB, Kansas City Chiefs | 4 |
| Green, Trent QB, Kansas City Chiefs | 4 |
| Pennington, Chad QB, New York Jets | 3 |
| Pennington, Chad QB, New York Jets | 3 |
| Romo, Tony QB, Dallas Cowboys | 3 |
| Romo, Tony QB, Dallas Cowboys | 3 |
| Kaeding, Nate K, San Diego Chargers | 3 |
| Kaeding, Nate K, San Diego Chargers | 3 |
| Wilson, Kris FB, Kansas City Chiefs | 2 |
| Wilson, Kris FB, Kansas City Chiefs | 2 |
| Harrison, Marvin WR, Indianapolis Colts | 2 |
| Harrison, Marvin WR, Indianapolis Colts | 2 |